Booking direct: what guests check first, and the arithmetic.

In short

• In a survey of 3,342 of its own members, The Guestbook found that 70% want a clear cancellation policy before booking direct, 63% a secure payment processor and 60% verified guest reviews. 62% worry whether the property is legitimate.
• On a $1,000 booking, Airbnb’s single 15.5% host fee is $155. Card processing on the same booking made direct through Stripe is $29.30 on a US card, or €15.25 on a €1,000 booking with a standard EEA card. Other cards and currency conversion cost more.
• That difference isn’t money saved. A direct route has its own costs, and platforms bring guests you would otherwise have to find. Direct works best alongside the platforms.

What guests check before they book direct

The Guestbook, a travel rewards platform, surveyed members of its traveller community between 1 April and 5 May 2026 and analysed 3,342 responses. It isn’t a representative sample: the company says the findings describe its own members and aren’t generalisable to all guests. As a checklist, it is still useful. Asked what would make them comfortable booking direct on a vacation rental’s own website, they said:

Asked about their worries, 62% said they worry whether the property is legitimate, 50% about payment security, 42% about unclear cancellation policies, 40% about resolving disputes and 33% about damage protection. 15% had no trust concerns.

What that means for your page

• Cancellation terms. Put the full terms on the page before payment: the deadlines, the refund amounts and what happens if you cancel.
• Payment. Take payment through a recognised payment provider, so guests pay by card on a secure checkout rather than by bank transfer to someone they don’t know.
• Reviews. Link to where your reviews can be checked, such as your listing profiles. Reviews guests can’t verify don’t answer the question.
• Your platform listings. Keep them live, and make the name, photos and details match your own page. 43% of the surveyed guests wanted to see the listing there too.
• Who runs the place. Say who you are and how to reach a real person. It answers the most common worry: whether the property is real.
• When something goes wrong. Say who to contact and how deposits or damage cover work.

The arithmetic of one booking

The same booking, two routes. On Airbnb, the single host fee is 15.5% for most hosts. Booked direct, every booking carries a card-processing fee. These are Stripe’s published standard rates on 28 October 2026.

Currency conversion adds 2% on Stripe’s euro pricing. Stripe doesn’t return its fee when you refund a booking, and a disputed payment costs $15 or €20. Other providers and negotiated rates differ. Under Airbnb’s older split-fee pricing, most hosts paid 3% and guests paid a separate fee instead; Airbnb is phasing that out.

What the arithmetic leaves out

Card processing is only one cost of taking bookings direct:

• The page and the booking system: a website, a calendar that stays in sync with your listings, and a way to take payment. Some booking systems also charge per booking.
• Protection: a deposit, damage cover or insurance that you arrange yourself.
• Paperwork: invoices and receipts, and local tourist taxes that a platform may collect for you in some places.
• Getting found: platforms bring guests. Direct bookings need their own way in, such as returning guests, referrals, social media and search.
• Your time: questions, payments, changes and disputes are yours to handle.

Part of what the platform fee pays for is on that list: demand, a checkout guests already know, reviews they trust and support when something goes wrong.

Is a direct route worth building?

Figures from the US suggest it can matter. For professionally managed US vacation rentals in the second quarter of 2026, direct bookings made up 21% of reservations but 29% of revenue, according to KeyData figures reported by RedAwning: fewer stays than on Airbnb, but larger ones. Both shares were down from a year earlier (25% and 36%), while Airbnb grew to 51% of reservations and 43% of revenue, and Vrbo held 20% of reservations.

So a direct route works best alongside the platforms, not instead of them: a page you can send to returning guests and link from your social media, while the platforms keep bringing new ones.

A checklist for your own page

• Your full cancellation terms, before payment.
• A checkout from a recognised payment provider.
• Links to where your reviews can be verified.
• The same name, photos and details as your platform listings.
• Who runs the property, and how to reach a real person.
• The total price, with mandatory fees and taxes, before checkout.
• How problems, deposits and damage are handled.
• House rules and what’s included.

Sources

1. The Guestbook, “What 3,342 travelers told us about booking short term rentals”, survey fielded 1 April to 5 May 2026.
2. Airbnb Help Center, “Airbnb service fees”, checked 28 October 2026.
3. Stripe, pricing and fees, United States, checked 28 October 2026.
4. Stripe, pricing and fees, Ireland, checked 28 October 2026.
5. RedAwning, “Vacation Rental Channel Mix 2026: Airbnb Hits 51% Share” (KeyData, Q2 2026), 8 September 2026.

Also readShoulder season: the September and October numbers, and what to change →